Skip to content

Gilbert Blythe and the Fairy Tale Love Story

2015 April 22

Gilbert Blythe

Over the weekend, a Canadian actor named Jonathan Crombie passed away suddenly from a brain hemorrhage. He was 48. Though certainly not a household name, millions of women mourned the loss of the man who played Gilbert Blythe in the television adaptation of the Anne of Green Gables books.

As a young girl, I was obsessed with Anne of Green Gables. I read all of the books (there are 8!).  I was an introverted girl who loved to read and kept myself entertained with elaborate stories in my head, just like Anne. I loved the flowery descriptions of Prince Edward Island, the wild Canadian island where Anne lived. Though the book was written in 1908 and described a way of life completely foreign to a girl growing up in the American suburbs in the 1990s, Anne of Green Gables was beloved by nearly every girl friend I know. Perhaps like the Little House on the Prairie books (which I also loved), the books were appealing precisely because of the alien lives they described, lives punctuated by hardships and the romance of simpler bygone times.

Even so, I was a little bit surprised at the outpouring of emotion surrounding Crombie’s death. There was even an article in the New Yorker, titled aptly enough, Why We Loved Gilbert Blythe. Writer Sarah Larson sums it up beautifully–the way Gilbert was so many young girls’ first love, a sweet and funny and charming boy who won all our hearts, even though he had to work for Anne’s (which probably just made us love him more). I suppose it makes sense that the loss of the actor who physically embodied the character (because we ALL watched the movies…A LOT) would mean so much to people. In a way, his death made us look back at our childhoods, maybe even remembering our own first loves and relationships.

Gilbert Blythe was like a human version of the fairy tale Prince Charming we’d been told we should love since before we could speak. He was mischievous and flawed and our age. He wasn’t a cartoon. He wasn’t perfect–he had personality. And even though many of us probably weren’t lucky enough to have the real equivalent of Gilbert Blythe in our lives, it was nice to know he could exist, out there somewhere. Even I still believe in him, deep down.


3 Responses Post a comment
  1. April 22, 2015

    I was so sad when I heard. I grew up with Anne of Green Gables- my grandparents gave me the books when I was really little and I still have them! The movies are amazingly well-cast, too, and Gilbert Blythe is such a great love interest.

  2. Jackie permalink
    April 22, 2015

    I was so depressed when Jon died. As a young adult, I pilgrimaged to PEI to surround myself with the story and went to the annual Anne parades. Not only was Gilbert Blythe my first love, he was what I compared all other boys to after him! I was in such a funk this weekend that I watched all of the Anne movies ( much to Matt’s objecting). It gave me a sort of peace that his character is still alive. The character Gil was smart,caring, and supportive- what all guys should be like ❤️

  3. Nancy permalink
    April 23, 2015

    I love Gilbert!! Believe in Gilbert :) Jackie, my mom and I also took a pilgrimage to PEI in 2009. I would love to rewatch the series!

Leave a Reply

Note: You may use basic HTML in your comments. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS